I began an earlier essay in this series with a modest critique of Enshittification (the book, not the phenomena). I felt that Cory Doctorow was being entirely too nuanced in failing to go any further than ‘maybe’ in equating enshittification (the phenomena, not the book) with capitalism (the economic system, not the American quasi-state religion). Under the present circumstance of widespread AI-driven systemic failures… It’s a question that needs to be revisited.

My own views on the subject are even less nuanced now than they were then. Enshittification, the seemingly inevitable decay of the digital products and services that have become the core planetary infrastructure of the twenty-first century, can absolutely claim oligarchic late capitalism as its root cause. There are other contributing factors (including possible retaliatory cyberattacks), but the fundamental, inescapable, issue that leads to all these other issues is that America – and thus the world – was so insufferably goddam stupid as to permit the planet’s core infrastructure to become the private property of a half dozen of the worst human beings on the planet. To be very clear: this did not have to happen.

Believing these individuals give a damn about the public good is right up there with thinking the stripper really likes you – although the cost runs higher than sweat-soaked dollar bills crammed into a g-string. Left unchecked, this delusion will cost what remains of our civilization and perhaps hasten human extinction (with or without robotic assistance). The stakes are too high to permit the current gilded age to continue without some sort of course correction.

That course correction will certainly be defamed as ‘socialism’ by the ill-informed, if not capitalism’s dreaded and misidentified manichean opposite, ‘marxism’. We can thank a century of pro-capitalist propaganda for at least part of this… but only part. The perception of entrepreneurs as somehow being heroic is an American bias baked not only into its culture, but foundational documents largely written and approved by proto-capitalist human traffickers (looking at you, Thomas Jefferson). The institutional privileges exercised by the Epstein Class have been with us for a long, long time. Long before the current U.S. president realized that he could commit murder on Fifth Avenue and child rape with equal impunity.

Those privileges need to end. 

This is not an argument in favor of the wholesale nationalization of digital infrastructure – not that there’s anything necessarily bad about that idea (it almost happened in Chile in the Seventies)… it’s just fundamentally unworkable. It’s also a bad idea from the shared perspective of proper IT governance and cyber-security. A principal likely cause of the previously noted network failure that led to a nationwide air traffic grounding order is almost certainly going to be the shoddy deployment of new systems into a production environment without proper testing or an effectively staged deployment program. A similar deployment, even one with better intentions, would be equally likely to cause interruptions and failures.

A far better idea, one we’ve discussed previously, would be the development of publicly owned and managed digital infrastructure as a federated system, minus the currently ineffective top-down management of centralized federal management that out-sources the hard parts to private enterprise. This would be a key component of a digital new deal, in conjunction with increased regulatory oversight of the companies providing services via this public infrastructure. Sam Altman has advocated for AI being treated as a public utility, with himself and his fellow oligarchs simply being the men collecting the bills. We should take him at his word on the first part and take a hard nope on the second part… at least in the absence of regulatory oversight.

We should also put into place sensible regulatory control over social media and enforce digital privacy without resorting to the hysterical notions like baking age verification into digital device operating systems. If digital technology reform cannot be accomplished at the federal level, there remains hope of accomplishing it at the state level – at least in states that benefitted from the Blue Tsunami. 

It is too early to write off the possibility of sensible reform at the federal level, even though Hakeem Jeffries’ effectively unopposed anointing as the next Speaker of the House does not bode well. Not only has Jeffries earned the nickname AIPAC Shakur the old fashioned way, working hard for Benjamin Netanyahu, He’s almost equally bankrolled by Big Tech. Although a number of the candidates we previously identified as potential members of a tech reform caucus are now on their way to Congress, their effectiveness could all too easily be blunted by Democratic Caucus senior leadership with other priorities. Fortunately, Chris Van Hollen’s challenge to Chuck Schumer for the role of Senate Majority Leader seems to be gaining momentum – and Van Hollen has made AI regulation a key component of that challenge, as well as a key distinction between himself and Chuck Schumer.

Whether Schumer or Van Hollen acquire the gavel in the Senate, they will be joining Jeffries in confronting a Republican Party that has, at least in the House Conference and the Executive Branch, learned nothing from their repudiation in the 2026 midterms. That intransigence, combined with a Democratic congressional majority well short of what is required to override the inevitable presidential vetoes, comes very close to ruling out any significant reform legislation over the next two years. 

Under other circumstances, this might be acceptable – but not under circumstances in which AI is now uncovering technology flaws more rapidly than human developers can patch them, much less circumstances in which AI-driven cyberattacks exploit these flaws within seconds of their discovery. In far less than two years, we will have moved from the temporary inconvenience of cancelled flights or missing emails to more lasting and potentially fatal consequences. We don’t have the luxury of indulging the shared fealty of corporatist Democrats and authoritarian Republicans to a neoliberal donor class that considers itself an aristocracy in the making. A political system designed around the speed of information transfer circa 1800 does not meet the needs of 2026 – and will be utterly obsolete by 2030… unless something meaningful happens now.


Images: AFR, Markus Spiske (Unsplash)