Craig Considine’s new book belongs to a tired genre: trick-fuck theories of Western decline that depend on misunderstanding the people they claim to explain.
By Omar Afra
Craig Considine has a vast Marxist–Islamist alliance to sell us, and I have a practical question: where the fuck do they meet? Who called it? Who agreed to what? I’ve spent forty-plus years around immigrant Muslim communities and leftist circles, seen the best and slimiest of both. My history tells me to ask which people, which partnership, which evidence. Turning that complicated mess into one army against Western civilization is bat-shit loco. People cooperate. The trick fuck happens when their shared objection to a war becomes a shared plan to destroy the West.
I was born in Beirut and came to Texas as an infant. We escaped political violence and made a home in a country I believe has helped foment plenty of it abroad. An immigrant paradox, lived out through publishing and building businesses in the brutal swamp that is Houston. Before Considine explains who is destroying the West, I’d like to know whether I’m included in it.
Full disclosure: I found his book on Facebook and posted a wonderfully vulgar taunt that merged 2 groups he seems to fear: gays and Muslims. It was stupid. It was low-res trolling for sure on my part. Considine, a senior lecturer at Rice University, replied: “Go back to Beirut!” I told him to go back to Ireland. A kinda rad travel plan if you ask me. My contribution was totally kid-shit; his made my birthplace the issue. I was a child and he was a xenophobe. Neither settles his argument. Both belong in the disclosure. Truth be told, Considine used to be a better guy. Maybe we can remember him from back in the day when his work promoted tolerance and inter-faith dialogue and forget the turd he is today? Comically enough, he lives here in Houston. Maybe one day I will see him in Valhalla ( it’s a bar on Rice campus ).

Where the fuck is this meeting? Who called it? Who agreed to what?
I haven’t read the complete book or audited its endnotes. I’m examining his own goofy ass essay, interviews, publisher’s description, and publicly attributed passages. The public pitch reads like the literary equivalent of diarrhea as it requires endless logical somersaults. I’m also don’t feel the need to subsidize anymore of this stupidity by actually buying the book. If he gives me a free copy, I am happy to give it a whirl.

The publisher’s case is an alliance hostile to Enlightenment values, America, Israel, and democracy. Getting these circles to agree on what Enlightenment values mean would already be a heavy fucking lift. Considine’s MEF interview supplies the formation: students as pawns, academics bishops, organizations knights, politicians rooks, foreign patrons kings and queens. An IDI review quotes the book, without page references, on politicians’ “power to vote and dictate law.” The MEF host reads another attributed passage at 6:41–7:15. Readers can inspect those sources.
Calling them chess pieces proves fuck all about who is moving them.
I believe in God and revelation; classical Marxist materialism starts elsewhere. The Quran’s obligations to the poor didn’t wait for Marx. Cooperation requires no conversion. Considine acknowledges tactical alliances, and examples exist: Iran’s Tudeh Party supported the revolutionary government before repression; HRW documented October 7 cooperation involving Hamas, the PFLP, and DFLP. Those facts establish particular relationships. They don’t enlist every American demanding a ceasefire. Networks can be decentralized; their reach still needs demonstrating.
Then the conservatives walk in. Gallup in July 2025: 32% approved of Israel’s Gaza military action, 60% disapproved; Republican approval was 71%. Pew in March 2026: 57% of Republican and Republican-leaning adults under 50 viewed Israel unfavorably. Different dates, different questions—country versus military action. Criticism refuses to stay in its assigned corner.
On July 15, 2026, 27 House Democrats backed Thomas Massie’s amendment against certain Israel military funding associated with Gaza and Lebanon—a pre-vote announcement, not a roll call. Did Massie become Marxist? Did the Democrats become libertarians? Or did they agree about a fucking policy?
Ron Paul opposes a U.S. takeover of Gaza; Palestinian Christian Justin Amash describes relatives killed at Saint Porphyrius Church; Tucker Carlson questions support for actions affecting Gaza’s Christians.
In July 2025, Cardinal Pizzaballa urged ending the war, aid, hostage release, and reconciliation. In August, released Israeli hostages and a captive’s widow urged ending the war and protecting remaining captives. MSF condemns the October 7 attacks while criticizing Israeli conduct.
Israeli security veterans’ September 2025 letter backed ending the war, Hamas-free governance, Israeli defense, and the Abraham Accords. If a shared demand establishes membership, this enemy camp is getting crowded.
Considine includes Jewish Voice for Peace, explicitly leftist and anti-Zionist. Jewish dissent isn’t missing; its variety matters. Anti-Zionists, critics of particular policies, and Israel supporters demanding peace cannot simply be assigned the same motives. These comparisons don’t disprove a particular partnership. They wreck the shortcut from shared demand to shared allegiance.
Opposing the same war does not put us in the same fucking army.
His podcast, from 23:00, cites unnamed activists’ messaging links and a student toolkit. A public NSJP toolkit celebrates October 7 and denies civilian status to “settlers.” I reject that bullshit. The document establishes disturbing rhetoric and coordinated organizing. Establish who adopted it; don’t assign its commitments to everyone else.
A study of 102 student-demand lists, April–May 2024, found divestment in 93%, financial transparency in 71%, academic boycotts in about two-thirds, and speech protections in 44%. Overlapping organizational demands, not a survey of every protester. ACLED counted 1,360-plus U.S. conflict-related demonstrations involving students, October 7, 2023–May 3, 2024: over 94% supported Palestine; 97% were classified as peaceful. Those are events, not people; peacefulness doesn’t rule out antisemitism or extremism, or settle claims about nonviolent coordination.
A catalogue of the worst incidents still needs a denominator.
Then look at Pew’s national figures. Unfavorable views of Israel’s government rose. Unfavorable views of Hamas stayed overwhelming.
Original Testset graphic. Pew survey toplines; 2026 methodology. Separate national estimates, not a measure of coordination.
| Survey fieldwork | Israeli government: unfavorable | Hamas: unfavorable |
|---|---|---|
| February 13–25, 2024 | 51% | 84% |
| September 22–28, 2025 | 59% | 84% |
| May 4–17, 2026 | 62% | 84% |
The 2026 survey covered 12,574 adults, May 4–17, with a ±1.3-point margin. The uncomfortable finding stays: 44% of Muslim respondents viewed Hamas favorably; subgroup 525, margin ±7.2 points. None of these measures establishes Marxist affiliation, coordination, or endorsement of a particular attack. Keep the distinctions even when the numbers piss you off.
Intelligence director Avril Haines reported in July 2024 that Iranian government-linked actors impersonated activists, encouraged protests, and supplied money. She also recognized good-faith protesters who might not know whom they were dealing with. Follow the interference. It doesn’t own everyone’s reasons.
A foreign state can exploit a real grievance. It does not make the grievance imaginary.
CRS in March 2026 reported $8.8 billion in cumulative Qatar-attributed disclosures through February 23, 2026, including gifts and contracts; a $1.1 billion Cornell contract covers Weill Cornell Medicine–Qatar in 2026–2032. Medical education and political organizing are different expenditures. Show the conditions and connections. A scary total proves fuck all about who directs a protest.
For cooperation with inspectable paperwork, try Washington. Testset has examined U.S.–Israel military integration. The House passed the Israel Security Supplemental Appropriations Act 366–58 on April 20, 2024.
| House party | Yes | No | Did not vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Republican | 193 | 21 | 4 |
| Democratic | 173 | 37 | 3 |
| Total | 366 | 58 | 7 |
Obama’s 2016 agreement pledged $38 billion for fiscal 2019–2028, subject to appropriation. Under Biden, the U.S. vetoed a U.N. Security Council ceasefire proposal in February 2024 backed by 13 other members; under Trump in June 2025, it vetoed another backed by the other 14. Different parties. Durable commitments.
HRW’s 2021 investigation and Amnesty’s 2022 report concluded Israeli authorities were committing apartheid. Challenge their evidence if you disagree. Calling the word Marxist doesn’t answer them. Bipartisan military support continued. Why must opponents share a philosophy before their cooperation makes sense?
Who agreed to what? In Washington, we can count the votes.
Listen to Considine’s podcast from 31:39. He distinguishes Ahmadiyya and Gülen communities from Brotherhood-aligned groups, describes attacks and a falling-out, and says a ceasefire was “not in the best interests of Israel” or America. His essay allows criticism of Israel, yet includes allegations of Islamophobia in its proposed test. What would a justified allegation look like? “Go back to Beirut” offers a starting point.
Considine distinguishes Muslims from Islamists, liberals from leftists. Those distinctions must survive application. Shared slogans won’t do it. Neither will the maneuver familiar from Greg Abbott’s Sharia panic, where Muslim political participation becomes evidence of something alien.
Citizenship is not a permission slip issued by well-heeled douchebags at Rice University.
If the West means equal citizenship and freedom of conscience, it includes Muslim critics of Israel, Jewish opponents of Zionism, Christians opposing a war, and conservatives opposing intervention. No community answers collectively for a government or an armed organization. My belonging does not require Considine’s permission, and a Rice affiliation gives him no power to grant it. I don’t owe Israel my agreement, and I don’t owe Considine my silence.
And Muslim political independence was already on display before October 7. Muslim and Christian conservatives were standing together: Muslim–Christian school opt-out rallies in Maryland, June 6 and 27, 2023; Dearborn school-book protests in October 2022, reported October 3, 2023. Muslims disagreed among themselves. Cooperation happened anyway. Nobody needed to settle the nature of God before deciding what they wanted their school board to do.
Pew in 2017 found 66% of Muslim adults identified with or leaned Democratic; 67% preferred larger government providing more services. ISPU’s 2025 survey found that among Muslims reporting a 2024 presidential vote, 50% chose Harris, 31% Trump, and 12% Stein. Their top-three policy priorities included Gaza at 35%, the economy and jobs at 41%, and traditional gender and marriage values at 3%. NORC surveyed 800 Muslim adults, April–May 2025, combining probability and nonprobability samples with calibration. These are reported choices, with all the limits that implies; they establish no single cause. The school protesters cannot automatically be identified with later Gaza protesters, either.
Support for Israel is a hell of an admission fee for a supposed natural ally.
Conservatives had partners on religious freedom, education, and family. Some people will work with you over schools and walk away over bombs. Their convictions may be quite consistent; your coalition simply isn’t their first obligation. Demanding agreement about Israel risks driving them toward people they otherwise profoundly disagree with. Democrats have no permanent claim on them, either—as my criticism of Hakeem Jeffries and AIPAC makes clear.
I can disagree with a Marxist about God and oppose a war beside him. I can disagree with a Christian conservative about Israel and defend religious freedom beside him. My convictions survive. So does my citizenship. Considine owes us evidence before assigning us a fucking chess piece.
I do not need to go back to Beirut to make that argument. I am making it from home.
Featured image: excerpt of cover of When Marx Meets Islam by Craig Considine, Pitchstone Publishing. Statistical graphic: Testset, based on Pew Research Center data.

Comments