A Thanksgiving survival guide for anyone who came to eat mash potatoes but got subpoenaed to defend an entire civilization.
By Omar Afra
Somewhere this Thanksgiving, somebody is going to explain the Middle East to a person whose family lives there. They will have read a total of zero books on the topic, traveled to none of the places involved, and assembled their position somewhere between a Blue Chew Gold advertisement and a video of a raccoon stealing cat food on Instagram. They will feel you owe them a response.
I know this achingly predictable routine. I have been dragged into conversations about Israel, Palestine and Islam in America more times than I care to count by an elaborate array of dumbfucks, hillbillies, and mongoloids. Someone I tangentially know approaches with a question at Target that turns out to be a poorly crafted speech. The oratory contains stupidity they found on social media that they regurgitate in a haphazard fashion. They would now like me to account for an entire religion, straighten out a century of history and respond to a clip whose source they cannot remember.
I came here to buy socks, motherfucker. Apparently, I have been subpoenaed on behalf of Islam.
What gets exhausting is the preparation gap. You can spend years reading about a subject, following its history, knowing people who live with its consequences, and still find yourself expected to treat somebody’s newly acquired certainty as an equally substantial contribution. They watched something before leaving the house. Now you have homework dude.
The pandemic gave us a particularly memorable version of this. Our social feeds began to resemble medical conferences where most of the participants had awarded themselves their qualifications that morning. A person would learn a technical term on Tuesday and be furious by Wednesday that the entire medical establishment had failed to consult them. Everybody had so much certitude that they ended up handcuffing themselves to premises they still cling to today.
And the specialties kept fucking changing. Suddenly it was military strategy. Then monetary policy. A dude at my gym became a self appointed expert on constitutional law. Then the history of a country the speaker had first heard of during the previous news cycle. The speed of professional development was extraordinary. Universities should have been embarrassed.
I have serious fucking questions about plenty of shit. I also have subjects I know almost nothing about. When those come up, I can usually manage some version of “I don’t know shit from shinola.”
Somewhere along the way, that sentence became more embarrassing than being spectacularly wrong at full volume.
Consider how differently we treat knowledge in other settings. Walk into a cardiologist’s office with two paragraphs from WebMD and announce that you will be supervising from here on out. Ask a historian of the Crimean War to set aside decades of research because a fella on your phone had a very compelling minute and a half. You should expect questions about what, exactly, qualifies you to be thiiiiiiiiiiiiis certain.
Patients should ask questions. Doctors should listen to them. Historians should be challenged on their evidence. But we generally understand that somebody who has done sustained work on a subject deserves a hearing before being informed that a walking bologna sandwich has solved it during lunch.
I would like to see a little of the caution people bring to wiring a ceiling fan applied to their pronouncements about entire civilizations.
And I would like us to recognize knowledge that arrives without an impressive title. Someone who has lived under a policy, speaks the language, knows the place or has family directly affected may understand things that never made it into your favorite commentator’s presentation. Before you explain their life to them, perhaps ask about it.
A person whose relatives are in danger may hear something very different in your entertaining debate topic. Being the Muslim in the room does not obligate you to spend the evening answering for every person who has ever said a prayer facing Mecca.
So I have developed a fail-safe method to avoiding these convos that are so damn excruciating:.
Have you read any books on the topic? Have you spent any time in the region? Does anybody in your family live with the consequences of the policies and conflicts we are discussing?
I am trying to find out whether there is a conversation here worth having. What have you actually done to understand this? Where does your certainty come from? Have you ever encountered the subject somewhere that required you to listen?
A passport stamp does not confer wisdom, and having family involved does not make every claim you make correct. But someone’s actual life ought to count for more than a clip you watched on the shitter.
As for books: sure, some are full of shit. A hardcover can contain a remarkable amount of nonsense. People become intensely interested in this possibility the moment you ask them to name a book they have read.
Read serious reporting. Read original documents. Listen to an audiobook. Spend time with people who know what they are talking about, including people who can explain where your preferred account falls apart. The question is whether you have stayed with a subject long enough for somebody to complicate your first impression.
A book has the indecency to keep going after it has made the point you wanted to hear.
You encounter a date that ruins your neat sequence of events. Someone you regarded as a villain turns out to have done something you must account for. Someone you admire does something indefensible. You discover disagreements among people you had been treating as interchangeable. Eventually, if you are paying attention, it becomes harder to explain millions of human beings with a sentence you borrowed.
You do not need a doctorate to recognize cruelty. But if you intend to deliver a sweeping explanation of a people, a religion or a war, do some fucking reading.
Our recent history also contains plenty of bullshit delivered by people with excellent credentials.
In October 2002, Pew Research Center found that 66 percent of Americans believed Saddam Hussein had helped the September 11 attackers. The 9/11 Commission later reported that it found no evidence Iraq had cooperated with al-Qaeda in developing or carrying out attacks against the United States.
Two-thirds of the country. That is a metric-fuck-ton of people getting something consequential wrong.

This belief received help from above. As Pew’s retrospective documents, Bush administration officials repeatedly linked Iraq with terrorism and al-Qaeda, blurring distinctions in the public mind even without directly accusing Saddam of planning 9/11. Official authority helped make an unsupported conclusion feel like common sense.
So spare me the idea that a suit, a degree or a television appearance provides immunity from bullshit. People with credentials can manufacture certainty, and people without them can ask the questions that puncture it. What matters is whether the claim survives examination.
Once a national certainty becomes a national embarrassment, I would like us to spend a little more time discussing how we acquired it. Who persuaded us? What did we fail to check? Why did disagreement make us angrier than the possibility that we were wrong?
There should be a little paperwork before we proceed to our next absolute conviction.
Then there was the Satanic Panic. In the 1980s and early 1990s, allegations of vast networks of satanic child abusers acquired a terrifying credibility. In his 1992 investigator’s guide, FBI investigator Kenneth Lanning described claims involving thousands of offenders and mass murder with little or no corroborating evidence. He warned that fixation on an elaborate satanic conspiracy could interfere with investigating actual child abuse.
Lanning also acknowledged that he had initially tended to believe the stories. As he examined them, he began questioning them.
Imagine that. An American encountered evidence and adjusted his fucking opinion.
That is the behavior I want to see rewarded. Give me somebody who can explain why they changed their mind. Give me somebody who can tell me where the evidence runs out. The person who has never needed to reconsider anything may simply have avoided every opportunity.
We had these problems before social media. We have since equipped them with exceptionally convenient distribution.
A 2021 study of more than 2.7 million Facebook and Twitter posts from news media accounts and members of the U.S. Congress found that posts about political opponents were shared roughly twice as often as posts about the speaker’s own side.
There is an enthusiastic audience for hearing that the other people are awful. Learning something that requires revising your opinion offers a less immediate thrill.
You can see the attraction. A good sneer is ready to go. A considered answer may require a few minutes and the admission that one part of the story remains unclear. Nobody gets to pound the table at the end of “I would need to check that.”
So we carry around these little coke-baggies of certainty, ready to open at dinner. The phrase has been rehearsed. The follow-up questions have not so much.
I hear the same habit in very different political vocabularies. One person says “the elites.” Another says “the discourse.” Another says “both sides,” as though locating the midpoint between two claims has saved them the trouble of checking either. Each has a phrase that announces where they belong. Ask for an explanation and you may get the phrase again, with emphasis.
Whatever your politics, your preferred people can be wrong. An independent thinker should occasionally reach a conclusion that inconveniences the people who usually agree with them.
Instead, we have adopted a reductive social-media-slop approach to subjects that require history, context and the occasional uncomfortable pause. Every complication has to be squeezed into a line you can repeat. When a human being turns out to require a second paragraph, the conversation gets gnarly.
And this is where Thanksgiving comes in. You are allowed to decline the convo.
You can say, “I’m happy to suggest something to read, but I’m not having this argument tonight.” You can say, “If you want to ask about my experience, I’ll tell you. I don’t want to spend dinner responding to videos.” You can also say, “I don’t want to talk about this,” and resume eating.
You do not need to administer my three-question entrance exam first. Even a well-read person can be an exhausting guest.
This is the part I have had to learn: somebody else’s appetite for an argument creates absolutely no obligation for me to provide one. I can care deeply about a subject and still refuse to spend my evening correcting a stranger’s account of it. Exhaustion proves very little about the strength of an argument. Sometimes it means you have explained the same thing a hundred fucking times.
And if you are the person bringing the subject up, try asking a question whose answer you actually want to hear. Let the other person finish. Bring something you have learned and something you are still trying to figure the fuck out. You may get a conversation worth having.
Otherwise, perhaps sit this one out. Read something longer than the caption. Allow for the possibility that your first impression could use some work. And for the love of God, let a dude eat.

Comments