Photo by K. Mitch Hodge on Unsplash

Stop me if you’ve heard this one before.

You just made a comment, online or in-person, that could be construed as somewhat critical of the current capitalist world order (in my case, usually a little more than ‘somewhat’). Almost immediately (if not quicker, if it’s in-person) you are confronted with the largely rhetorical question of whether or not you are ‘some sort of communist’ – largely rhetorical because the person asking the question typically has no idea that there are different ‘sorts’ of communist. 

But also because it’s not a question that requires (or even expects) an answer. It is a reflexive expression of an engrained manichean dualism, typical of both the propagandized and the religiously indoctrinated. Because I am old enough to have living memory of the cold war, I had always assumed it was a response conditioned by decades of propaganda.

But now I am not so sure.

The increasing ‘double down’ on this response, in the face of growing evidence that we have entered the apocalyptic end stage of capitalism, is beginning to look a lot more like the response of religious zealots to questions about the tenets of their faith, or the reflexive defense of Donald Trump by his dwindling base of low-information supporters. It is not just a matter of conflicting world views. It is the defense of something that is an emotionally coded article of faith.

The U.S. is currently two weeks short of celebrating the 250th anniversary of one of its foundational documents, The Declaration of Independence. But a strong case can be made that this year has already seen the 250th anniversary of a much larger document that can, in many ways, also be seen as a foundational document of the national identity, if not formal governance, of the United States of America.

Originally published on March 9, 1776, Adam Smith’s The Wealth of Nations contains not one word explicitly referencing ‘capitalism’ as such. However, at over 700 pages, it effectively qualifies as the ‘old testament’ upon which America’s later secular faith in capitalism is founded. It is, in its own way, just as much a product of the 18th century enlightenment. It is no surprise that Thomas Jefferson, principal author of the Declaration, thought well of Wealth of Nations. Why would he not? As a member of the planter aristocracy that counted as capital other human beings, Jefferson was a protocapitalist of the highest order.

It would require almost a century before the inherent contradiction between the principles of the Declaration and the practices of the slave owning majority signing it could be settled in part by a civil war and the formal emancipation of enslaved peoples. The equally pervasive contradiction between the fantasy notion of ‘virtuous capitalism’ and the reality of massive wealth inequality has never truly been addressed at all. Recurring progressivism in the 1890s, 1930s, and 1960s have resulted in slight gains – typically offset within a generation by pushback in both policy and rhetoric.

The most significant such pushback is almost certainly the massive wealth transfer initiated by that genial snake-oil merchant Ronald Reagan and marketed as ‘trickle down’ economics. We can thank Reagan for the current Epstein class of obscenely wealthy oligarchs. We can also thank him for the ant-communist policy and rhetoric inevitably leading to the currently reflexive condemnation of capitalist critique as “communist”.

That binary, ‘us vs. them’, ‘with us or against us’ rhetoric would later be appropriated as part of Bush the Younger’s hapless Global War on… well, something. Reframing the ‘them’ as swarthy-complected alleged terrorists, instead of more vaguely defined Eastern Europeans and domestic Bolsheviks, was a remarkably easy reframing. You could even keep capitalists in the role of ‘us, the good guys’, with arch capitalist Darth Cheney running the war while simultaneously padding his pockets.

That binary framing is also being used by Donald Trump and his various grotesque henchfolk in their current domestic war against brown people and urban America. But that rhetoric, like the war itself… is unraveling.

Capitalism as a secular state religion had a good run. It managed to organize the proletariat against their own class interest for a good one hundred fifty of the two hundred and fifty years of the American Experiment we are all trying to convince ourselves to celebrate as the anniversary heaves into view to the accompaniment of gladiatorial combat matches and failed efforts at turning the Reflecting Pool into a Jed Clampett-style ‘Cement Pond’. But it is highly unlikely that the U.S. will make it to a tricentennial if this secular state religion remains in place.

That’s not to say that capitalism itself necessarily needs to go away. The classic capitalism Adam Smith first described in 1776 is a far cry from the neoliberal corporate capitalism currently choking the planet as it wrings out every last penny of stockholder value. A return to an earlier, truly free market variation, under proper regulation and governmental oversight, could not help but be an improvement over present conditions.

The core flaw in the myth of capitalism is the idea that infinite financial growth and consumption is sustainable on a planet of increasingly finite resources. The core flaw in the myth of American Democracy is the idea that democracy can be sustained in the absence of a civic commitment that holds wealth accountable. The combined flaw in America’s secular state religion of mythologized and sanitized capitalism is that it eliminates any possibility of public policy discourse that might steer the world into a more sane and sustainable future.

Capitalism as a state-sponsored quasi-religion needs to go the fuck away. Capitalism is not inherently fascistic, but fascism is inherently dependent upon unregulated capitalism. The sooner we can get over worshipping the rich, the sooner we can get back to the essential business of eating them…