Image courtesy of Open Source Data Center Atlas

In the previous article in this series, we took an overview glance at previous discussions/attempts at a ‘Digital New Deal’ and the challenges of implementing any such thing at a federal level in the current United States – and rapidly came to the conclusion that, absent the hoped-for major political realignment in the upcoming midterm elections, any such reform effort had best be scalable… and able to operate independently.

This is not an ideal scenario, but it may be all we have. The days of the U.S. Department of Justice being willing to break up monopolies, enforce public safety, and regulate products that place the public at risk may someday return, but they are certainly behind us for now. And, as anyone who has ever built a network knows, it’s a lot easier to scale up than scale down.

That said, there are certainly steps that can be taken at local/state/regional levels to move the United States toward a Digital New Deal. In some ways, a decentralized approach may be more stable and robust. Also, a decentralized approach avoids the necessity of watering down legislation in progressive states into something more acceptable to those inclined toward knee-jerk obsequity to large-scale corporate capitalism (looking at you, Texas). In no particular order, here are my thoughts on scalable opportunities for internet reform that can be undertaken anywhere.

Increasing Community Ownership of Digital Infrastructure

In our earlier comparison of the internet to electrical utilities, we briefly took note of one of the legacies of the original New Deal: Utility coops, created as part of the effort to bring electrical service to rural areas where the profit incentive to build power grids was slim to none. Those community coops still exist. Many of them provide internet connectivity to their customers, almost all of them are having to deal, one way or another, with the corporate data centers sprouting like toxic mushrooms all across the country.

Those utility coops, present to some degree in every state of the union, are a natural and logical place to begin the process of transferring ownership of the essential infrastructure of the 21st century from corporate interests to the people whose lives and livelihoods depend upon that infrastructure. And there is no reason whatever to not add a new round of additional coops, designed and created for the specific purpose of ensuring reliable and cost effective internet and data management services that are directly answerable to the communities they serve.

Of course, the issues that led to the New Deal creation of the Rural Electrification Administration differ almost diametrically from issues new, internet-specific utility coops would be intended to address. Back then, the issue was that there was no money to be made from providing electrical service in rural areas. The problem now is that entirely too much money is being made from monopolistic control of essential digital infrastructure. But community collective ownership of essential infrastructure still provides an answer.

Promoting Open-Platform Digital Commons

This series of articles began with the observation that Cory Doctorow’s Enshittification is 100% spot-on when it comes to the problems of platform lock-in and monopolistic practices of digital platform owners, remarkably vague on the question of what to do about it. This vagueness may be more feature than bug, given Doctorow’s affiliation with EFF, which depends heavily on funding from Silicon Valley.

Given that Silicon Valley is not a hand that presently feeds me, I have no problem with taking a bite at solving the problem. And I think that one possible solution is the development of open-source / open-platform equivalents to the lock-in of Facebook, Twitter, Threads, etc. The primary reason I continue to have a presence on Facebook is the number of old friends who are too digitally inept to be reached any other way. But what if there was an alternative that was just as easy, didn’t sell your data, and could seamlessly integrate with any other social media platform?

Making such a thing cool enough to attract users is a problem in its own right, but the last time I checked, there were a fair number of tech-savvy people watching their professional careers go sideways. There’s not much hope for the ones that still buy into the fantasy of being a cool tech-bro CEO, but I suspect I am not alone in being willing to accept a more modest role promoting the digital public good. Or, for that matter, join a fucking union.

This is absolutely something that state and local governments can fund, encourage, and promote. You should not have to use a corporate-owned platform to talk to your old granny…

Ensuring Digital Sovereignty of Government Operations

… or pay your fucking taxes, for that matter. Once again, for those who haven’t read the previous articles, the Digital Sovereignty that governments outside the United States are increasingly finding necessary should also be considered a states right. State and local governments should be able to conduct their basic business without concern that Big Tech providers like Google and Microsoft may have as little respect for their digital privacy as has been made abundantly clear in the case of governments outside the United States. 

As the U.S. staggers toward an election that the regime in power absolutely intends to subvert, the symbiosis between that regime and its big tech enablers becomes increasingly problematic. How can we, the people, trust that the administrative state managed by our elected officials is not being subverted by the corporate platforms those administrative states run on?

We can’t, obviously. On the other hand, would I trust a state network of publicly owned data centers running something like NextCloud to securely conduct business on my behalf? Yeah, actually.

Regulating Social Media and Artificial Intelligence

This is where it gets difficult… but also gets inevitable. Once again, looking back at the example of Tobacco Regulation, regulatory efforts in various U.S. states began long before effective Federal-level regulation finally became a concrete reality under the Obama Administration. 

There is already ample evidence that social media constitutes a risk to public mental health that at least equals the physical health risk that tobacco continues to pose. There is a growing body of evidence that artificial intelligence poses a comparable, if not greater risk. The decades-long gap between early state-level efforts at tobacco regulation (circa 1950) and federal regulatory consolidation (circa 2010) is not acceptable in this context, not when the public risk in question continues to grow at an exponential rate. If we wait until the U.S. Tricentennial to regulate AI, we may as well assume that AI will essentially be calling the shots (possibly literally).

The current regime’s coziness with Big Tech and tech products certainly extends beyond Dear Leader’s fondness for AI-generated images of himself as a crowned, shit-spewing fighter pilot or Jesus or whatever other childishness erupts from his decaying mind. The Tech Bro Oligarchs that lined up for the inauguration/coronation have made very clear that they intend to pursue the current trajectory of surveillance, incarceration, and increasingly obscene levels of wealth inequality. And while AI certainly has other uses, corporate owned and managed AI is 100% their tool of choice for reaching their ends. LLMs are a great tool, but a tool that must be regulated.

And a power that should be in the hands of the people.

Protecting User Privacy and Autonomy

As digital sovereignty is to states, digital autonomy is to people… and businesses. Protecting that autonomy on shared digital commons should be as much of an internet reform priority as anything else on this list, even though it has a large dependency on most of the other items – except in one glaringly obvious case that stands on its own.

I’m referring to the swarm of OS-level age verification laws currently being proposed at both state and federal levels – none of which are technologically feasible as written, all of which potentially would provide exploitable backdoors that bad actors would use for the same ostensible purpose these laws purport to oppose: online exploitation of children. A significant problem (but hardly the only one) is that these laws are proposed by people with only the vaguest idea of what a “digital device operating system” even is – they just know that the devices they barely know how to use are equipped with them.

Instead of signing off on the latest round of hysterical moral panic, law makers with a serious interest in internet reform should be focused on making the real exploiters – Meta, Twitter, et. al – accountable. And that brings us to the last item on the list.

Taxing Big Tech (or providing incentives for not using it)

I saved this one for last for at least a couple of reasons. To begin with, state and local governments with a serious interest in internet reform could accomplish virtually everything else on the list without having to pull tax policy into the mix. More than that, tax policy would likely be excluded for the same reason that any package of internet reform policies is almost certainly not going to be labeled as anything remotely resembling a “Digital New Deal” – even though intelligently designed tax policy could be one of the strongest tools at the non-federal level to pursue Big Tech. Before you can intelligently design tax policy, you have to be able to intelligently discuss it… and that hasn’t been possible in the United States for at least forty years.

But that doesn’t mean it wouldn’t be a good idea – particularly the incentivization part.

Providing tax breaks to businesses using local, community-owned digital infrastructure in preference to Big Tech is probably less likely to be attacked as government overreach by people who call themselves ‘libertarian’ (with zero regard for liberty) or ‘capitalist’ (without a single penny of actual capital). That these same people will likely write off the idea of community digital infrastructure as ‘socialism’ virtually goes without saying – but part of the reason for taking a localized, scalable approach to internet reform is to focus on wins where you can get them.

Get enough of those wins, in enough places, and you can take the same policy framework, bolstered with actual data, into other places. Do it enough times, and you truly do have a ‘digital new deal’ – whether anyone wants to call it that or not.