Photo by Helena Lopes on Unsplash
I have no prior experience whatever as a labor organizer, but I do have some applicable experience herding both literal and figurative cats. I have never had anything close to a million dollar personal net worth – but having worked in technology roles for over twenty years, I understand all too clearly how John Steinbeck’s famous (and occasionally disputed) description of pro-capitalist American workers as “temporarily embarrassed millionaires” applies with particular after the fact accuracy to people who do tech for a living.
It is, unfortunately, fairly engrained in tech industry culture.
Socialism never took root in America because the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat, but as **temporarily embarrassed millionaires.
– John Steinbeck
Update ‘poor’ to ‘middle-class’ and ‘millionaire’ to ‘billionaire’, and you have a pretty fair description of the mindset of the millions of people who have recently found out that existing billionaires will happily hand over their livelihood to digital robots, even more happily add the one-time salaries of displaced workers to dragon-like obscene hordes of unearned wealth.
Those updated terms are an inevitable logical result of the ongoing consumption of late capitalism, which will not be satisfied until the entire planet has either been consumed or turned into continent-spanning ghettos, with the wealthy elites either moving to Mars (in your dreams, Elon) or exclusive orbital habitats (also unlikely, but at least theoretically possible). What remains the same is the determination of the exploited to identify with their exploiters.
That determination is especially keen in a field built on the mythology of ‘Tony Stark’ inventor/entrepreneurs, stock option offerings from start-ups, and the highly notional idea that fifty hour weeks spent staring into a screen might somehow result in bringing to market the next killer app that just might, somehow, get enough clicks to result in a buy-out offer from one of the billionaire boys with their rocketship toys.
That determination is exacerbated by the long-standing infatuation common among tech workers with libertarianism – even if it tends to be more the ‘soft’ libertarianism of pot-smokers than the ‘hard’ libertarianism of gun-toting closet Republicans. The idea that ‘big government’ is more of an existential threat than uncontrolled capitalism is especially appealing to people who have acquired or maintained middle-class status by way of being smart and being willing to work their asses off. As Cory Doctorow has observed in Enshittification and elsewhere, the strategy of ‘vocational awe’ has worked well for decades as a means of convincing tech workers that they were somehow ‘special’. It’s easy to consider the people getting thrown under the bus as someone else’s problem.
Until the day you wind up joining them.
All that said, there are groups and organizations trying to reach out to tech workers as members of labor.
The Tech Workers Coalition was originally (and unsurprisingly) founded in Silicon Valley, currently has 12 active chapters across North America and Europe, and has been active since 2014. Their values statement reads (in part) “The Tech Workers Coalition seeks to redefine the relationship between tech workers and Bay Area communities. Through activism, civic engagement, direct action, and education, we work in solidarity with existing movements towards social justice and economic inclusion…”. Their website is an incredible asset to anyone interested in tech worker organizing, member or not.
The Campaign to Organize Digital Workers (CODE-CWA) has over 7,000 members and is more directly tied to the infrastructure of U.S. mainstream unions, having been launched in 2020 as an initiative of Communication Workers of America (CWA). They describe themselves as a “fighting union”, working to “build the voice and power necessary to ensure the future of the tech, games, and digital industries in the United States and Canada”.
United Information Workers and Collective Action in Tech may or may be currently active organizations. Neither of their online presences appear to have been recently updated. Washington Alliance of Technology Workers was formerly engaged on behalf of workers at Microsoft, Amazon, IBM, and Intel before choosing to affiliate with CWA.
An interesting and open question is what it will take to escalate cat-like quasi-libertarians into further solidarity and direct action. Tech Workers Coalition seems most likely, on the face of past actions and stated values, to take a direct stance against what I’ve described as the Capitalist Colonization of the Internet.
But they aren’t going to get very far on their own.
Decolonizing and reclaiming the internet from rentier robber barons is going to be a massive exercise. The current state of enshittification took the better part of three decades to occur. If deshittification takes an equal timeframe, we are all basically fucked – but unless we are all incredibly lucky, repairing that damage is still going to take years.
It’s going to take people sweating out small fortunes in student loan debt being willing to take public sector jobs that haven’t been created yet, jobs that will certainly not match the pay scales of the tech industry at its apex. But those jobs and pay scales are likely not coming back, no matter what.
It’s going to take national, state, and local governments taking on the plutocrats and holding them accountable, as well as investing in public digital infrastructure and creating those public sector information worker jobs. It’s going to take public advocacy groups and, yes, unions forming a common front and social alliances.
The tech folks need to grow up and lose the libertarian fantasies. Elon Musk is a shithead who got born on third base, bought all the tech he claims to have invented, then credited himself with a home run that is 100% inherited wealth, coopted public infrastructure, and other people’s hard work. There is nothing admirable or worth emulating about these people.
What is truly admirable is working hard, playing by the rules, and contributing back to the communities and families that helped you. It may not be as sexy cool as working yourself into exhaustion trying to knock out that killer new app, but it also might not take quite as much toll on your relationships, your health, and your sanity.
I genuinely feel for all those temporarily embarrassed millionaire cool cat libertarians who are watching the billionaire class flush their jobs down a golden toilet – how could I not? I’m essentially one of them. But I got over my own libertarian tendencies sometime between the dot-com bust and the first time Dear Orange Leader bamboozled enough hapless rednecks to make his way into the White House. We aren’t going to vibe-code our way out of this crap. What is required at this point is massive social reform.
And maybe just a bit of solidarity.

Comments