Photo by Maharsh Borad on Unsplash
The term ‘digital new deal’ (not to be confused with ‘green new deal’) has been in modern use in various contexts at least since the government of South Korea announced infrastructure plans for one in 2020. The term has since been appropriated, with varying degrees of authenticity, by think tanks ranging from honest efforts at public policy to thinly veiled technology advocacy consortia. It should be noted that none of these groups have a tangible footprint in the United States, which has had a poor track record at ‘new deals’ ever since the original one was prematurely ended by the advent of World War Two. Joe Biden’s own Green New Deal contained some elements of digital infrastructure reform, but mostly focused on physical infrastructure and addressing the concerns of climate change – reason enough for the current U.S. president to overturn it, had simple childish spite not been sufficient.
While the United States waits to determine whether or not it remains a functional democracy, it remains worthwhile to consider what policy initiatives might become possible if the hoped for mid-term electoral ‘Blue Wave’ actually happen. The reason it is worth considering is that there is going to be a fairly narrow window for implementing any such policies.
While the current U.S. president can be counted on to steadfastly oppose any sort of federal-level digital public policy beyond lavish paybacks to his tech bro oligarch enablers and deregulation of Bitcoin grifters, he is not (at least not yet) ‘President for Life’. Even if he were, there is only so much medical science can do to prolong his self-shitting spiral into final dementia and collapse. And there remains at least the hope that the final collapse will occur in some form of federal detention.
But it would be naive to assume that the leader of the current corrupt regime in power is the only obstacle to informed digital public policy. The shambolic remains of the regime’s puppet political party will remain united in ignorance of science and contempt for public good long after their dear leader has finally followed Elvis out of the building. Nor can one hope for much better from the sham opposition party, which is no less addicted to oligarchic subsidy than the current party in power. They will only pay attention to such matters if they understand that their own power depends upon it.
And there remains the unfortunate likelihood that the days of the U.S. as a functional democratic republic are already running out. If the outcome in November lives down to Dear Leader’s corrupt expectations, it will be time for an honest assessment by states not part of the mid-continent wasteland that voted him into power in the first place – basically, to borrow words from The Clash: Should I Stay or Should I Go?
Which means that any sort of ‘Real Deal’ Digital New Deal needs to be scalable as fuck– Needs to be based on principals and concepts that work at any level from local to state to federal.
That’s not going to be easy. No engineer, digital or otherwise, would accept the job of building something that might serve a hundred users or a million. That would be on a par with not knowing the difference between a millionaire and a billionaire (which most Americans apparently don’t, but that’s a rant for another day).
And not everything within scope of such a plan is equally scalable. We’ve previously discussed multiple strategies for regulating Big Tech, but the ultimate regulatory remedy, breaking up Tech Monopolies, is only applicable at the Federal level. That doesn’t mean there are not comparable remedies that can be applied at the state level – but in order for them to be effective, there needs to be enough coordination between states that bad corporate actors will actually feel the pain.
And that is also going to be a problem.
The two overall largest states in America, California and Texas, can be counted on (for entirely different reasons) to have very close to zero interest in any sort of digital new deal that places the interests of people above the interest of Big Tech. In California’s case, the obstacle is that most of those companies maintain headquarter operations in Silicon Valley and have a long history of bankrolling and lobbying California politicians. In Texas’ case… oh, god where do we even start? So much stupid, so little time.
But because time is short and stakes are high, we are not going to get stalled out on inevitable issues of duplicity, stupidity, and corruption, it might be best to focus instead on what is possible and doable at different levels of scale ranging from the local to what might be expected at the state level (at least in states that at least try to have a functioning democracy) to what could possibly be expected at the federal level, minus the current regime (or at least minus its sycophantic enablers).
By focusing on what does scale, we should at least be able to make it as far as a ‘concept for a plan’ – and we’re not even running for president. A concept should be good enough. Expect one in the next article in this series.

Comments