Image by FMT Designs
Right now, we’re waiting for the last major round of U.S. primary races before the Midterm Elections. After the August 11 primaries, the congressional candidate list isn’t going to change any further until Massachusetts and New Hampshire hold their primaries in early September… but we’re not going to wait for that.
The running list we’ve already started of Democratic/Independent congressional candidates who at least name drop tech reform on their campaign websites should pretty much be a done deal shortly after August 11. We’ll finally be able to do some hard analysis on the data and figure out who really seems ready to lead on these issues. We’ve already called out a few candidates who don’t seem to understand that pimpin’ for crypto is not internet reform. If anyone else jumps on that bandwagon, we’ll mention that as well.
If we were also examining Republican/Libertarian campaign websites, the list of crypto-pimpers would undoubtedly be much larger – but honestly, why bother? We’re trying to locate potential members of Congress interested in technology regulation and technology policy reform, which would certainly challenge the deep love Republicans and Libertarians share for obscenely wealthy and entitled tech oligarchs. Examining their websites for regulatory tendencies is a fundamental waste of time. And probably even more offensive to someone, like myself, who has done web for a living (campaign websites are not works of art).
Meanwhile, while we’re waiting to finish out that list, we can further reflect on the early precursors of real AI that have been surfacing in science fiction over the last sixty or so years. We’ve already looked at the AI imaginings of Robert Heinlein and Isaac Asimov. It seems only fair to give equal time to the third of the so-called ‘big three’ of classic science fiction… and talk about Arthur C. Clarke.
And, of course, HAL.
Even though both Asimov’s robots and Heinlein’s revolution-friendly supercomputer made it into print before HAL 9000 had either film or print exposure, it’s hard to argue against the idea that HAL is the absolute archetype and prototype of the blandly destructive AI that fucks shit up and then offers an apology. Even people who have never seen 2001: A Space Odyssey instantly recognize the line “I’m Sorry, Dave… I can’t do that” – and understand entirely when astronaut Dave Bowman breaks into his space ship’s data center and gives HAL a lobotomy.
Both Bowman and HAL made appearances in the sequel film and multiple other print appearances in additional sequel novels (2010, 2061, 3001).
It should be mentioned that, of the three classic sci-fi literary grandmasters, Clarke was the vastly greater writer – far more in the visionary tradition of writers like Olaf Stapeldon or Stanisław Lem then the techno-obsessed “hard sci-fi” school from which Asimov and Heinlein emerged. HAL was an unnervingly prophetic character in 1968. Thanks to Clarke’s poetic genius, he remains so to this day.
And that’s why it might not be a bad idea to pay him a fitting tribute.
Whether or you buy Clarke’s claim that it was ‘mere coincidence’ that the letters of HAL’s acronymic derived name (“Heuristically programmed ALgorithmic computer”) are one letter up the alphabet from “IBM” (I don’t), it’s an easy enough acronym to repurpose. The “Harmful Algorithm Limitations” Act works for social media, the “Hosting Administration and Local Control” act works for data centers, and the “Human-prioritized AI Licensing”act wouldn’t be too shabby for AI regulation. To be clear, none of this is far removed from the James Bond inspired acronym obsession of the 1960s… but it is also fun. Fun I am happy to pass on to paid staffers of the hoped-for Tech Reform Caucus of the next U.S. Congress.
It should be noted as well that HAL eventually outgrew his earlier homicidal tendencies (at least in the books) and became a ‘good guy’ of sorts – at least after he was firmly under the regulatory control of his formerly human astronaut buddy.
There is, I think, a lesson to be had there. I do not question the overall value proposition of large language model technology (full disclosure: Duck.ai helped me with the acronyms), what I do question is the value of this transformative technology being left, without regulatory oversight, in the hands of the worst predatory vulture capitalists in human history. HAL could be reformed; the best we can do with the techbro oligarchs is tax and regulate them out of their current form of existence (the way we should have done twenty years ago).
Better late than never… right?

Comments