Photo by Nathan Kuczmarski on Unsplash
Issac Asimov wrote about a lot more than just robots and galactic empires… but that’s what he’s mostly remembered for now. The current Apple TV adaptation of his Foundation series will go a long way toward perpetuating that – even if it does get a few things wrong.
To be clear, I do not regard the original novel trilogy as any sort of sacred text. It was genre fiction written in the early 1940s, and it reads like it. Liberties taken with this material to make it relatable to a twenty-first century general audience are entirely understandable, and largely improvements. It was also necessary to make changes in order to make the work distinct from the sincere flattery of Star Wars.
One of the things the television adaption gets surprisingly right (if somewhat belatedly) is Asimov’s Laws of Robotics… including the overarching zeroth law that Asimov had to add when he retconned his original Robot stories into the Foundation continuity:
- A robot may not harm humanity, or, by inaction, allow humanity to come to harm.
- A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.
- A robot must obey the orders given it by human beings except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.
- A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.
Why this isn’t already hard-coded into every single damned large language model implementation system (or other AI product) is one damned good question. The only answer that immediately comes to mind is that the tech bro oligarchs shoving this shit down our collective throats are apparently already hard-coded with another science fictional ethical code: The Ferengi Laws of Acquisition. One could argue that the current regime running the United States is similarly coded, but for the obvious facts that (a) the current regime considered itself unbound by any laws, and (b) the current regime leader considers himself bound solely by the Ferengi ‘zeroth law’ AKA ‘the unwritten rule’: when in doubt, just make shit up.
We are a mere three months out from finding out if the made-up shit extends to preventing free, fair, and uncontested elections in the United States. If it does, out of control AI might be the least of our problems in comparison to an out of control dictatorship. But, assuming at least the base level of American moral and constitutional norms can remain intact, there is increasing evidence that at least some of the incoming members of the next congress understand the need for technology regulation (that is, the ones that aren’t already pimpin’ for crypto).
An ‘Asimov Amendment’ would be a fine tribute to the scientific visionary and prolific writer who managed to predict so much in both fiction and non-fiction – as well as get a few things massively wrong. It would also go a long way toward repairing some of the damage the current U.S. regime has done to America’s reputation and standing in the rest of the world.
Not all of the damage; it is going to take more than constitutional guardrails on AI technology to reverse the current trend toward digital sovereignty from American Big Tech companies, and much, much more to restore trust in U.S. trade and diplomatic relationships – that is going to require sufficient system change to guarantee that the current epic shitshow of fascistic abuse, crony capitalist corruption, and reckless militarism cannot reoccur.
But it would be a goddam good start.
At the very least, we would be proving that the institutional change mechanism provided for in the U.S. Constitution still works, likely as part of a package of amendments – sort of the way we proved we were serious about repairing the institutional flaws that led to the Civil War in its immediate aftermath.
Do I actually believe this is going to happen? No, probably not. The more likely outcome, I’m afraid, is some degree of soft secession, in conjunction with the sane segments of the country taking the serious business of regulating AI into their own hands. Not quite the optimistic future Asimov predicted in works like The Bicentennial Man, but very little of the twenty-first century (at least so far) has lived up to the techno-optimism of mid-twentieth century sci-fi. Basically, we’re in Blade Runner… minus the replicants (again, at least so far).
But if we’re going to live in a cyberpunk dystopia, maybe it can at least be a better regulated dystopia than the one we’re in right now.

Comments