Photo by Barbara Burgess on Unsplash 

There was nothing particularly new about Orange Julius Caesar’s latest incoherent Oval Office Address. Not the aggrieved butthurt over his 2020 electoral loss to Joe Biden, not the baseless claims of Chinese election interference, certainly not the continued threats to ‘do something about it’ if the upcoming midterm elections deliver results not to his liking.

What is somewhat new is the increased urgency and anxiety these incoherent ramblings bring to concerns that the United States has already lost its democracy, squandered it away the moment a convicted criminal was administered an oath to defend a Constitution he has never read, cannot understand, and violates as casually as he would a teenage beauty pageant contestant.

It was already a given that Trump would attempt to interfere with any federal-level elections past the one that put him into power. The question of how far he is willing to go is an uneasy question that will be answered for us all in the upcoming months leading to the next anniversary of January 6, 2021. An engineered ‘national emergency’ is almost certainly in the works, even though no such emergency grants the president any authority whatever to ‘supervise’ elections. The deployment of federal paramilitaries to polling places, if it comes to that, should be the final line in the sand. At that point, the democratic republic that Benjamin Franklin opened wondered if Americans would be able to keep… is effectively lost.

Leaving only the question of what to do about it.

The idea of soft secession has been gaining currency ever since this petulant oaf was placed back in power. It is essentially ‘quiet quitting’ at the state/federal level, but with a slightly different power dynamic. Instead an apathetic employer doing the bare minimum to keep a revenue source they despise, states (blue states, obviously) would withhold revenue from a federal government determined to use that revenue to fund expensive and arbitrary wars, funnel money into hapless flyover country red state hellholes, and send murderous masked thugs into the very cities largely paying their wages. 

And it’s a bad idea.

It’s a bad idea for a number of reasons, starting with the extreme likelihood that it could be the beginning of an escalation into outright civil war – and not the nice, tidy, conflict between color-coded armies queued up in organized battle lines depicted in historically inaccurate old movies. It would be the other kind of civil war… the one where you get murdered by your neighbors.

But even if soft secession doesn’t escalate into the real deal, it’s still a bad idea for other reasons. It would further widen the Blue/Red cultural divide and effectively cement it into place. It would further damage a U.S. economy already suffering under Trump’s disastrously inept economic policies and further widen the wealth inequality gap – driving rural red state inhabitants into even further depths of poverty. It would confirm, not repudiate, the hateful rhetoric of division that has dominated the last decade of American public life. Once Trump is finally – thankfully – gone, there may be an opportunity for reconciliation, an opportunity to heal the ruptures he created. That can’t happen if the Americans who opposed the rhetoric of division decide that those who embraced it are beyond redemption.

On the other hand… that opportunity may be gone already.

It can be safely assumed that there is going to be at least one constitutional crisis in the lead-up to the mid-term elections, but the real crisis is going to be the period between the election itself and the assumption of office by winners of the expected/hoped-for ‘Blue Wave’ rejection of Trump and his enablers. The same period in 2020 was when Trump assembled a criminal conspiracy to overturn the results of that election, ultimately turning to mob violence and insurrection when the conspiracy failed. It is foolish to suppose that pattern is unlikely to repeat. Expect calls for mob violence across the country.

If those calls are answered, if the institutions we depend upon to preserve order fail yet again, it will be difficult, if not impossible, to make the case for actively working to maintain a federal union that cannot meet the most basic requirement of the social contract upon which all government is fundamentally based: Preserving the safety of those who consent to be governed.

There will certainly be institutionalists who believe the answer to an overturned election is to try harder in the next one, meeting the exact terms of one of the more popular definitions of insanity. They will almost certainly be the same institutionalists who failed to contain Trump in the first place. Gender irrespective, they suffer from a state/federal-level version of battered woman syndrome. Those of us who have already had enough… will not be listening.