Tom Morello has spent thirty years selling revolution to people who already agree with him. His latest innovation is selling it through Ticketmaster.
By Omar Afra
Photo by Chris Anthony
Tom Morello fucking loves being a celeb. He seems capable of sniffing out a camera from six blocks away. Mention a documentary about popular music and you can practically hear him dragging up a chair ready to proclaim whoever the subject is as “foundational.” Assemble an all-star benefit and somewhere a guitar is warming up to make a noise like a fax machine being waterboarded. If rock and roll requires someone to explain resistance into a microphone between celebrity cameos, Morello appears to maintain an open calendar. He has become something stranger than a political musician: the entertainment industry’s revolutionary-in-residence, permanently available to reassure us that the raised fist remains operational as long as somebody remembered to laminate its backstage credential.
I am not particularly interested in proving that Morello secretly does not believe his politics. He probably does, which is almost more interesting. The remarkable thing about Morello is how completely his version of revolution has learned to coexist with the institutions revolutionary culture was once supposed to make uncomfortable: rapacious corporate ticketing, frivolous Rock & Roll Hall of Fame honors, celebrity culture, premium hospitality, all-star supergroups, name-dropping famous friends and increasingly famous children can now sit comfortably beside the vocabulary of workers, resistance, solidarity and liberation. Capitalism did not defeat Tom Morello’s revolution. It appears to have given it a killer hospitality rider.
That contradiction reached something close to conceptual perfection at Morello’s October 3 Power to the People Festival at Merriweather Post Pavilion. Bruce Springsteen, Joan Baez, Public Enemy, Foo Fighters, Dave Matthews, Killer Mike, Serj Tankian, Rise Against, Jack Black and a small galaxy of recognizable people assembled around Morello for an event organized around political participation, justice and the power of ordinary people. This is precisely the kind of collision between music and political life Testset has argued may become increasingly important as live music becomes more valuable in a world saturated by machine-mediated culture. The problem begins when you stop reading the poster and start exploring the economics, searching for transparency, or reading the ticket menu.
Admission reportedly began at $125 for People’s Park; admittedly not exorbitant against today’s typical ticket prices. From there, the people could improve their relationship to the revolution with a $225 People’s Pavilion ticket, ascend into a $375 Solidarity Circle, or achieve revolutionary consciousness through a $1,500 Robinhood Package with access to a VIP Super Suite. Somebody sat in a room, attached the name Robin Hood to a $1,500 premium hospitality product and apparently no-fucking-body said that the metaphor might be getting away from them. For those without an 8th grade understanding of English lit, Robin Hood famously redistributed wealth downward.
The festival said net VIP proceeds would benefit charitable organizations, and sure, that matters. Expensive tickets can absolutely be used as fundraising instruments, but fundraising and hierarchy are separate design decisions. You can ask someone wealthy to contribute $1,500 without constructing an exclusive physical experience around the contribution. You can let that donor finance twelve people’s access rather than purchasing a more comfy version of solidarity for himself. A donation does not require an observation deck. Side note: industry production professionals routinely refer to this as the “poser deck.”
Testset has been writing about this trajectory for years, including the danger that music festivals increasingly become playgrounds for the affluent and the broader erosion of the independent ecosystem necessary for live music to remain culturally healthy. Morello did not invent bougie VIP culture, premium segmentation or the increasingly stratified economics of concerts. What he did was place revolutionary nouns on top of them. A VIP enclosure became a Solidarity Circle, a luxury hospitality package became Robinhood, and nearly the entire commercial architecture survived intact while the vocabulary developed class consciousness.
This is not an argument that concerts cost nothing. They cost a fucking fortune and I have personally lost my ass too many times to count. Anyone who has produced them knows how quickly staging, sound, labor, security, sanitation, insurance, medical coverage, transportation, power and artist expenses turn an exciting idea into a spreadsheet capable of causing chest pain. Our broader coverage of the live-music industry’s structural crisis exists precisely because these economics are real, and our reporting on how independent festivals are being squeezed has never depended on the fantasy that enthusiasm somehow pays a lighting vendor. The political question is not whether somebody has to pay. It is who.
Once you call the fucking thing Power to the People, the means of production become part of the review. Ticketmaster was Merriweather’s primary online ticketing route, and that arrangement was not invented specifically for Morello. Merriweather’s normal online ticket sales run through Ticketmaster, which means there is no evidence Morello personally sat at a table comparing independent ticketing companies and announced that he wanted the revolution processed by Live Nation’s ticketing arm. The more revealing question is why he selected an event architecture in which Ticketmaster was already waiting at the door. And to be superduper clear: Live Nation / Ticketmaster were the pillars behind Rage Against The Machine’s most recent tour. Of course. Who else do you partner with to present the return of the seminal anti-capitalist rap-rock act?
For Power to the People, Morello had gathered an extraordinary concentration of wealthy and influential artists. Those people possess something besides correct opinions: resources. The organizers could have raised production underwriting before announcing the show, asked performers who could afford it to work without guarantees, sought donors prepared to subsidize general access, scaled the production to committed resources and built an independently registered free event in a park, field or other appropriate public space. That version would still require insurance, security, permits, medical planning, bathrooms and professionals getting paid. It would simply place the cost somewhere other than on the people whose empowerment was printed across the poster.
That distinction matters because Ticketmaster is not some invisible plumbing fixture inside the concert economy. Testset has spent years examining the consolidation surrounding Live Nation, Ticketmaster and the contemporary live-music business, including the concentration represented when Live Nation, Ticketmaster, iHeartRadio, SiriusXM and Pandora sit inside increasingly interconnected corporate systems. We have argued that independent infrastructure is essential to independent culture precisely because the infrastructure eventually shapes what appears possible inside it.
Morello chose a world in which Ticketmaster was already the final boss. For a musician whose carefully crafted identity rests upon interrogating who controls the machinery, accepting the machinery as an immutable starting condition seems worth interrogating.
The easiest response would be that enormous political concerts simply cannot be free, except Morello has already participated in a rather inconvenient counterexample. In 2010, Rage Against the Machine staged a giant free show at Finsbury Park after “Killing in the Name” beat The X Factor to Britain’s Christmas number one, and Morello later recalled that the band covered the production costs themselves, right down to the portopotties. Audioslave also played an enormous free outdoor concert in Havana, while Morello’s 2008 Justice Tour deliberately kept most admission around ten dollars while supporting local organizations. This is not some teenager who has never seen a festival budget. Morello knows exactly what production costs because he has already participated in decisions to put those costs somewhere other than the audience.
That makes the $1,500 Robinhood suite something more than an easy joke. Morello knows what cheap political music looks like, and he knows what free political music looks like.
Somewhere between Finsbury Park and Merriweather, the revolution discovered craft cocktails and temp-controlled shitters.
A much more interesting Power to the People would have asked wealthy participants to underwrite free admission. If somebody wanted to contribute $1,500, terrific: instead of purchasing insulation from ordinary attendees, that contribution could finance the participation of people who otherwise could not afford to attend. The donor could receive a receipt, a thank-you and the exact same patch of humanity as everybody else. Let the supposedly important people stand elbows to assholes with the proletariat for an afternoon. They might survive the experience.
For once, wealth could purchase somebody else’s access instead of the buyer’s separation. That would be a material experiment in solidarity rather than merely a lexical one, and it would actually distinguish the political event from the commercial concert economy we have repeatedly criticized. The point would not be to punish rich fuckers by making them uncomfortable. The point would be to demonstrate that donating money need not automatically reproduce another putrid hierarchy inside the experience the money supposedly exists to democratize. Rich folks get max-comfort in every other human ritual whether it is on flights, buying groceries, you fucking name it. Now they gotta be treated as nobility at supposedly subversive live music events?
Morello had also spent considerable time learning how to build precisely this sort of celebrity-dense event. As musical director for Ozzy Osbourne and Black Sabbath’s Back to the Beginning, he helped organize a giant production around abbreviated sets, extremely fast transitions and combinations of famous musicians playing with other famous musicians. The revolving-stage architecture allowed an enormous quantity of talent to pass across the event without ordinary festival changeovers swallowing the day. I actually think the format is excellent: festival fatigue is real, attention spans have changed, and an endless succession of interesting collaborations can be far more entertaining than watching every artist independently reproduce an exhaustive ninety-minute touring set.
The problem is not that Morello learned something useful from Ozzy. The problem is confusing an excellent entertainment format with a profit stream disguised as a revolutionary political form. Morello has become exceptionally skilled at assembling celebrity. Celebrity itself has become one of his instruments. Give him Springsteen, Dave Grohl, Jack Black, Public Enemy and enough phone numbers and he can apparently assemble half the rock establishment before lunch, but the ability to summon famous people is not the same thing as the ability to summon power.
The festival’s financial language makes that distinction even more important. Its announcement said a portion of ordinary ticket proceeds would benefit VoteRiders and HeadCount while 100 percent of net VIP proceeds would go to charity. Those numbers could ultimately represent a meaningful contribution, but “a portion” is not a percentage and “net” is not an amount. Because the event has only just happened, demanding a completely reconciled final settlement immediately would be idiotic; vendors invoice, expenses settle and transfers take time. Explaining the formula does not. Sunlight is the best antiseptic.
The organizers can tell the audience what percentage “a portion” represents, which expenses reduce VIP revenue before it becomes “net,” which artists took guarantees, which waived them and whether travel or production reimbursements were treated differently from performance fees. They can eventually disclose what the venue operation cost, what the ticketing economics were, what Morello himself received if anything, and exactly what VoteRiders and HeadCount ultimately collected. If the answer is that the stars worked for free and an enormous amount of money reached organizers, excellent. Publish it and make critics eat the column.
Revolutionary politics should be unusually comfortable with transparent accounting.
Morello has already seen how quickly benefit-concert arithmetic can turn into online mythos. After Back to the Beginning, an enormous charitable figure circulated before people closer to the accounting disputed the number. The lesson is not that charity concerts are inherently scams; it is that gross receipts, production costs and charitable distributions are different categories and that celebrity bluster is not an accounting method. Power to the People should publish the books because a political event asking its audience to trust the lockbox is an oddly unrevolutionary arrangement.
Money was not the only scarce resource being distributed. Morello’s teenage son Roman also appeared within the festival’s musical ecosystem, and the relevant question has nothing to do with abusing a fifteen-year-old or pretending the kid cannot play guitar. He kinda crushes it. The problem is nepotism, and the music industry is increasingly beginning to look less like a meritocracy than a system of dynastic succession. Gracie Abrams can be ( sort-of? ) talented and still be J.J. Abrams’s daughter; Roman Morello can be talented and still receive access that thousands of equally gifted teenagers will never even be allowed to compete for. Talent does not cancel inherited proximity. When your father can text Grammy winners, the distance between the garage and a festival stage becomes considerably shorter.
That makes Roman’s appearance particularly ridiculous at an event called Power to the People. If Morello wanted to redistribute opportunity, he could have held an open call and found some terrifying sixteen-year-old guitarist from Baltimore, a working-class kid from D.C., a Palestinian teenager, literally anyone without a hereditary backstage pass. Instead, one of the scarce things being distributed was stage access, and a shit-ton of it went to the curator’s son. His performances were not sparse; he was fucking ubiquitous. The revolution apparently opposes inherited power everywhere except the guest list.
The absence of the rest of Rage Against the Machine becomes interesting in that context. Morello assembled Springsteen, Foo Fighters, Public Enemy, Joan Baez, Dave Matthews, Killer Mike, Serj Tankian and a remarkable number of other famous musicians, yet Zack de la Rocha, Tim Commerford and Brad Wilk were not on the announced Power to the People bill. That is an extraordinary amount of revolutionary celebrity orbiting one quarter of the band whose political credibility supplies so much of Morello’s cultural authority.
Nobody outside their circle knows what that means personally, and there are documented reasons not to manufacture a soap opera. Wilk has said Rage would not tour or perform live again, de la Rocha’s serious Achilles injury devastated the reunion tour, and rumors abound that Zach sees Morello as too horny for cash. No, there is no public statement from the three declaring that Morello is an insufferable celebrity revolutionary whom they refuse to accompany. There is also no reason to pretend the observable pattern is meaningless.
Morello increasingly conducts an all-star revolutionary celebrity circuit in which Rage’s cultural mythology is always present but the rest of Rage usually is not. Note the hyper-cringe Prophets of Rage tour he did with members of Public Enemy and Cypress Hill. The Rock & Roll Hall of Fame supplied the clearest previous image. When Rage was inducted in 2023, Morello attended alone. De la Rocha, Commerford and Wilk did not attend, and Morello himself acknowledged their differing perspectives about participating. Rock’s ultimate institutional embrace of Rage Against the Machine therefore produced the peculiar spectacle of Tom Morello accepting that embrace without Rage Against the Machine with the corniest speech ever given.
The following day made the contrast almost offensively photogenic. Zack de la Rocha was photographed at the enormous Washington march for Palestine while Morello had attended the Rock Hall and posed backstage with a ceasefire sign. I do not know what Zack privately thinks about Tom Morello and neither does anyone who is not Zack, but I know which photograph contains the institutional trophy and which contains the street. One man brought protest symbolism inside rock’s ceremonial establishment, while the other skipped the ceremonial establishment and appeared among protesters.
Testset has wrestled with this distinction before, including an earlier piece asking whether Zack de la Rocha should reconsider participating in a Rage reunion at all. What has become stranger since then is the extent to which the collective’s revolutionary authority survives as cultural currency while its most omnipresent public representative operates increasingly without the collective beside him. Rage Against the Machine’s authority was created by four musicians. Tom Morello’s revolutionary celebrity franchise belongs increasingly to Tom Morello, and it increasingly smells like Axl’s Chinese Democracy era GNR.
Sure, In the most limpdick ways possible, Morello has publicly supported Palestinians and praised artists willing to speak forcefully about Gaza. Fine. But none of that has required him to surrender much of anything. He has not put his body, fortune, career infrastructure, touring relationships or celebrity access meaningfully at risk; he has mostly done what a famous progressive musician can do from a stage, a phone or a group letter without materially disrupting his own life. For somebody who has spent three decades constructing an identity around standing with the oppressed, that is an astonishingly low bar.
Signing letters and issuing correct statements on Gaza is not revolutionary praxis; it is the minimum viable conscience of a person with good politics and a publicist.
If Morello wants to inhabit the mythology he has spent his career selling, then act like the moment is as extreme as he says it is: finance something, refuse something, lose something, put your body somewhere inconvenient, get on the fucking flotilla if that is what it takes to demonstrate that solidarity can involve personal risk rather than another carefully worded statement. Otherwise the politics remain morally agreeable, publicly visible and almost completely impotent.
If Morello were simply a musician with progressive opinions, that record would be perfectly respectable. He has spent thirty years asking to be evaluated according to a much more ambitious standard. Revolution is not some incidental political interest attached to his biography; it is embedded in the product, from the imagery and speeches to the mythology surrounding Rage Against the Machine. Under extraordinary historical circumstances, the relevant question is therefore not whether Tom Morello signed the correct statement. It is what somebody with Tom Morello’s resources, money, access, international celebrity, institutional security and extraordinary network actually does once signing the statement becomes the bare minimum.
Gaza makes the insufficiency of celebrity solidarity impossible to ignore. Much has been said about the way constant images of suffering can transform viewers into passive witnesses and about the media architecture through which mass violence becomes narratively sanitized. Morello represents a related problem at the level of celebrity activism: the correct statement, the correct sign, the correct photograph and the correct letter can all be morally preferable to silence while still being materially inadequate to the moment.
Morello is not an unknown opening act wondering whether mentioning Palestine will destroy his career. He is one of the most famous political musicians alive. He can apparently summon Springsteen, organize giant events, generate media attention on demand and reach millions of people without asking anybody’s permission. Between posting a statement and physically putting yourself in a war zone lies an enormous continent of material action: finance organizers, underwrite Palestinian artists, fund humanitarian efforts, provide legal support, create free political events, give Palestinian organizers the prime speaking positions, redirect cultural access toward people without it, and use celebrity not merely to express solidarity but to transfer money, attention and institutional leverage toward those with less power.
That is the standard Morello himself taught generations of listeners to expect. We did not invent it to fuck with him.
The Ticketmaster relationship becomes even more uncomfortable against that background. Ticketmaster Israel identifies itself as part of Live Nation Entertainment and operates commercially in Israel, while Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and Israel’s own B’Tselem have all used the framework of apartheid to describe Israeli domination of Palestinians. None of that means Power to the People funded Israeli military operations, and it does not establish that Morello is some secret Zionist. It does however make it reasonable to ask whether the corporate infrastructure surrounding an explicitly political festival was ever considered politically.
If Ticketmaster was effectively inseparable from Merriweather’s online ticketing system, the question returns to the beginning: why was Merriweather indispensable? Were other venues considered, was independent ticketing considered, and was building a free public event ever seriously thought through? Nobody participates in contemporary capitalism without contradiction, and demanding absolute purity is intellectually useless. The revolutionary distinction should be a willingness to notice the contradictions and sometimes choose the more difficult road because the easier road reproduces precisely the arrangement you claim to oppose.
The entire festival also rests upon a conception of celebrity politics that ought to look considerably shakier after the 2024 election. American entertainment culture demonstrated a remarkable ability to assemble famous people behind Kamala Harris. Bruce Springsteen endorsed her, Taylor Swift endorsed her, Beyoncé appeared with her, Oprah supported her and Eminem participated in campaign activity. Donald Trump won the election. That does not prove celebrity endorsements are worthless, but it certainly should end the childlike assumption that cultural visibility converts automatically into political power.
Kurt Vonnegut understood the humiliation of this problem decades ago when he looked back at the extraordinary cultural opposition to the Vietnam War and compared the combined political force of respectable American artists to a custard pie dropped from a stepladder six feet high. His point was not that artists should shut the fuck up. It was that expression and power are different things.
That is ultimately the question buried inside the title Power to the People. A festival can gather a dazzling collection of famous musicians, produce thrilling performances, raise real money, create genuine pleasure and generate oceans of flattering photographs. None of those achievements automatically demonstrate that power moved anywhere. If the organizers want the word power, we should be allowed to ask what power changed hands, toward whom, through what mechanism and how anyone outside the promotional department would know.
Of all people, Olivia Rodrigo just put on the festival Tom Morello wishes he organized. Her inaugural Daisy Chain Fields took over Irvine’s Great Park, drew roughly 45,000 people, and was built around an all-women lineup whose artists all performed for free so the money could actually move toward the cause rather than disappear into guarantees. Ten nonprofit organizations working on reproductive rights, maternal health, legal advocacy and women’s welfare were embedded into the event itself, appearing onstage and operating inside a dedicated philanthropy village; Rodrigo announced $10 million for those groups before the gates even opened, and Melinda French Gates matched it, bringing the total to $20 million. Los Angeles Times That is what activist fervor looks like when it leaves the poster and enters the production model: use a public park, ask the stars to waive their fees, put organizers at the center, raise an obscene amount of money and tell everybody exactly where it is going. Rodrigo is 23 years old and built a clearer material relationship between celebrity, sacrifice and political purpose than Morello managed with thirty years of revolutionary branding behind him.
Imagine instead that Morello had announced essentially the same event and made free public access the organizing principle. The production budget gets raised before the stage is designed. Wealthy performers, patrons and donors underwrite it. Stagehands, technicians, medics, sanitation workers, security personnel and union labor all get paid because there is nothing revolutionary about making working people donate labor to a millionaire’s politics. The production gets scaled to the actual money available rather than the fantasy version everybody wants for the press release, and the remaining capacity is distributed freely and transparently.
Someone who wants to contribute $1,500 can absolutely do so. That person has just helped twelve people attend rather than purchasing insulation from twelve people. They receive a receipt and gratitude rather than a private suite, then enter the same safely managed crowd as everybody else. Maybe someone bumps into them, maybe someone spills a beer, maybe for four hours a wealthy person experiences a cultural space where money cannot purchase a better class of citizenship.
Duder, call that the ‘Solidarity Circle’.
The same philosophy could govern the stage. Famous artists still headline because famous artists attract enormous audiences, but significant opportunities are reserved for musicians selected through an open process rather than inherited networks. Community organizers receive prime speaking time rather than functioning as civic parsley between celebrity performances. Palestinian organizers speak for Palestine, labor organizers speak about labor and voting-rights groups build continuing relationships with people after the amplifiers shut off. The whole thing streams free worldwide, and when the event settles, the organizers publish the underwriting, performer compensation, production expenses, charitable transfers and every other number necessary to understand where the money actually went.
That would not overthrow capitalism in an afternoon. It would at least make the economic organization of the event consistent with the politics and goofy hi-res Communist style guide printed across it, which is already more interesting than another collection of celebrities congratulating one another for agreeing.
Morello should understand that possibility better than almost anybody alive. He has already participated in the free concert, already toured with ten-dollar tickets and already spent thirty years teaching his audience that economic arrangements presented as inevitable are usually political choices made by somebody. That makes the contradiction particularly irritating. If $125 was a choice, defend it as a choice. If $375 solidarity was a fundraising mechanism, show us what it raised. If the $1,500 Robinhood suite generated extraordinary resources for organizers, publish the number. If Merriweather and Ticketmaster were selected because every alternative was financially impossible, explain the alternatives that were examined.
What does not work is selling conventional hierarchy beneath revolutionary language and expecting the language to do all the political work. Don’t sell me a Solidarity Circle without showing where the solidarity goes. Don’t sell me a Robinhood suite unless Robin Hood’s money demonstrably reaches somebody outside the suite. Don’t route the revolution through Ticketmaster and then spend the afternoon lecturing the audience about concentrated corporate power. Don’t give the curator’s kid one of the most valuable forms of access in music without expecting questions about who else was offered the same doorway. Don’t assemble half the celebrity class and confuse famous people appearing together with ordinary people acquiring power.
If Power to the People ultimately means Power to the People Who Can Afford the Ticket, then Morello has not created a revolutionary alternative to the concert economy. He has created a particularly well-branded product inside it. That is why he is such a useful case study: he may sincerely believe nearly every political position he proclaims, genuinely want a more just world and ultimately raise meaningful money for worthwhile organizations, and none of those things dissolves the central contradiction. They make it more revealing.
Tom Morello has spent a career warning that capitalism can absorb rebellion, transform it into an image and sell the image back to you. He just seems not to have noticed what he has become.

Comments