Abbott won’t debate Hinojosa. Paxton keeps dodging Talarico. Patrick hasn’t answered Goodwin. At some point, refusing to stand across from your opponent and defend your record stops looking like strategy and starts looking like fear.
By Omar Afra
texas reI am not a Democrat. I have no particular interest in becoming one. I am an independent voter in Texas, and one of the fairly modest things I expect from somebody asking for the privilege of governing 31 million people is the ability to stand on a stage, without a teleprompter or a friendly interviewer, and defend what the hell they have done. Apparently, that is now too much to ask.
Texas is less than a month from early voting, and Gov. Greg Abbott has not agreed to debate Democratic gubernatorial nominee Gina Hinojosa. Attorney General Ken Paxton, the Republican nominee for U.S. Senate, has not agreed to debate Democratic nominee James Talarico. Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick has not publicly accepted Democratic nominee Vikki Goodwin’s challenge to debate. Axios independently reported on Sept. 25 that Abbott had not agreed to debate Hinojosa and that Texas was among the major races with no agreed debate.
THE TEXAS DEBATE RECEIPTS
Abbott: an October invitation, a September invitation, no agreement
Hinojosa formally accepted the NBCUniversal Texas and Hearst Newspapers invitation on July 1. The proposed one-hour debate was scheduled for Oct. 15 in Fort Worth and was to be broadcast statewide in English and Spanish. On July 17, her campaign said Abbott had allowed the organizers’ response deadline to pass. Because that assertion came from an opposing campaign, it should be identified as such, but the larger fact became independently verifiable later: Axios reported on Sept. 25 that Abbott had not agreed to debate Hinojosa and that his camp had offered no explanation. Abbott did debate Democratic challenger Beto O’Rourke in 2022.
There was also a proposed Sept. 25 Nexstar/KXAN debate, and that date passed without one. Hinojosa’s campaign says Abbott has ignored four proposed debate invitations while she has accepted all four. The count belongs to the Hinojosa campaign; the absence of an agreed Abbott-Hinojosa debate does not.
Paxton: “Of course we are going to debate.” Then nothing.
Paxton presents the most elaborate paper trail because his campaign explicitly promised a debate. On July 16, after Talarico announced that he had accepted invitations from NBC/Telemundo/Hearst Texas, WFAA/TEGNA and KXAN/Nexstar, Paxton senior adviser Nick Maddux told the Texas Tribune: “Of course we are going to debate James Talarico and we look forward to engaging with potential debate hosts.” The Paxton campaign confirmed that it had received the invitations.
The three proposed Texas debates were scheduled for Sept. 22 in the Rio Grande Valley, Oct. 6 in Dallas and Oct. 13 in Austin. The Tribune also documented Paxton’s longer history of winning elections without debating: he declined a Republican attorney-general primary debate in 2022, did not accept his Democratic opponent’s invitation in 2018 and rejected a general-election debate in 2014. The 2026 Republican Senate primary involving Paxton, John Cornyn and Wesley Hunt also produced no debates.
Then the communications apparently stopped. WFAA reported that it had communicated with Paxton’s campaign for weeks about organizing a debate but had received no response to its messages since Aug. 24. Talarico subsequently accepted a CNN debate invitation. Paxton’s campaign did respond to that one by rejecting the proposed forum and attacking CNN and its prospective moderators, but that objection became considerably less useful on Sept. 24 when Talarico publicly proposed another venue: Fox News, moderated by Bret Baier. As of that day, the Texas Tribune reported that Paxton had yet to accept any debate invitation.
Then came another option. Texas A&M’s MSC Wiley Lecture Series invited Paxton and Talarico to an Oct. 14 debate at Rudder Auditorium. At some point the obvious question becomes how many venues a man needs. The chronology is painfully simple: Paxton’s campaign said he would debate, his opponent accepted multiple invitations, and Paxton has not accepted one reported to date.
This overlaps with something Testset has already examined in Why Does the Right Love AI Slop So Much?: political communication increasingly happens inside environments candidates can manufacture themselves through targeted advertisements, synthetic images, social posts, friendly interviews and algorithmically distributed video. In that earlier piece, I called part of the mechanism a trick-fuck: content does not necessarily have to withstand sustained inspection if it can create the desired emotional response before inspection happens. A live opponent and a live follow-up question introduce considerably more friction.
Patrick: three debates requested, no answer reported
The Patrick case requires considerably fewer words. On Aug. 17, Goodwin appeared on Spectrum News’ Capital Tonight and publicly requested three debates against the three-term lieutenant governor. “I think voters deserve to have the candidates side by side, talking about the issues of the day,” she said. Spectrum News contacted Patrick’s campaign for a response, and the outlet reported that it received none.
Very quiet about debates. Very loud about Islam.
The lack of debate participation is particularly conspicuous against another documented feature of Texas Republican politics this year: Islam and Muslims have received an extraordinary amount of attention. This does not require guessing what is inside a politician’s head; start with the Republican Party of Texas’ own documents.
At its June convention in Houston, the party adopted “Don’t Sharia Our Texas” as an official 2026–28 legislative priority. The Republican Party of Texas’ own published priority calls Sharia an “incompatible, seditious, subversive, competing enemy system” and calls for its advocacy or implementation to potentially trigger criminal punishment, exclusion from public service, denaturalization and deportation. The same official document proposes withholding taxpayer funds from entities the party says promote Sharia and stopping developments characterized as “Sharia-compliant.” Those are not words supplied by Democrats, CAIR or Testset; they are published by the Republican Party of Texas.
The convention itself went considerably further. The Texas Tribune reported from the state GOP convention that Muslim delegates and attendees were shunned while anti-Sharia rhetoric veered into what the newspaper called “outright Islamophobia.” Mohamed Hussein went to the convention looking to determine whether there was a place for a conservative Muslim inside the Republican Party and left in tears after former pastor Rick Scarborough told him that if he embraced the beliefs he was defending, he should leave the country. The Tribune also reported that outgoing GOP chairman Abraham George advised two Muslim delegates to leave the Republican caucus and join the Democrats. This was not some Twitter rando with eight followers; this happened at the Texas Republican Party convention.
The episode was not isolated. The Tribune later documented how Texas Republicans had sharpened their attacks on Sharia and Islam, including the creation of a Sharia Free Texas Caucus and proposals from some conservative figures involving Islamic dress, Islamic schools and professional licensing. The newspaper also gave Muslim Texans and Islamic scholars space to explain the enormous gulf between that political rhetoric and the way they understand Sharia: not as a competing Texas government, but as a religious and ethical framework encompassing prayer, charity, honesty, fasting and personal conduct.
That distinction matters because the Republican Party’s official language is not coy. It calls Sharia an enemy system, contemplates criminal punishment for advocating it, and calls for denaturalization and deportation. It is an official legislative priority.
The focus on Muslims has also moved well beyond the party convention. Reuters reported in September that Republicans were making Muslims a campaign issue in the 2026 midterms, specifically identifying Abbott’s campaign against the Muslim-led North Texas development formerly known as EPIC City. Reuters noted that Abbott invoked alleged “sharia courts” in attacking the project, a characterization disputed by the developers and Muslim civil-rights advocates.
Abbott also turned his attention to airport ablution facilities. In August, Reuters reported that Abbott sought federal investigation of washing facilities at Dallas-Fort Worth International Airport and Houston’s George Bush Intercontinental Airport. Muslims use such facilities for ritual washing before prayer. Abbott argued that the accommodations might violate antidiscrimination requirements tied to federal funding, while Muslim organizations described the intervention as anti-Muslim political theater.
Then there is the development formerly called EPIC City and now known as The Meadow. The proposed North Texas community, marketed in part toward Muslim families and planned to include housing, retail, a school and a mosque, has faced repeated state and federal scrutiny. The Texas Tribune reported in February that HUD opened a fair-housing investigation after the U.S. Justice Department had already closed its own inquiry. The Justice Department said developers had agreed to comply with federal fair-housing laws, while an earlier Texas Workforce Commission matter ended through a conciliation agreement.
None of this requires every reader to reach the same conclusion about what constitutes Sharia, whether every investigation was justified or whether every Republican criticism of a Muslim institution should automatically be labeled Islamophobic. Those are separate questions, and the narrower factual contrast is enough: Abbott, Paxton and the Texas Republican Party have demonstrated enormous willingness to make forceful public arguments about Muslims, Sharia and Muslim institutions, and Abbott and Paxton have exercised actual government authority in matters involving Muslim Texans. Yet Abbott has not agreed to stand across from Hinojosa and publicly defend his broader record, Paxton’s campaign said he would debate Talarico and has not accepted one of the reported invitations, and Patrick’s campaign did not answer Spectrum when Goodwin asked him for three debates.
For context, this is not exclusively a Republican disease. Axios found candidates from both parties declining or avoiding debates around the country this year. Call them out too. I don’t give a shit which letter follows the candidate’s name. I am not arguing that Democrats are virtuous and Republicans are cowards by definition; I’m saying that the people asking Texans for enormous governmental power should be willing to stand across from the people trying to replace them and defend what they have done.
This article happens to be about Texas, and these are the Texas receipts. Abbott was invited, Hinojosa accepted, and Abbott did not. Paxton’s campaign said, “Of course we are going to debate James Talarico,” Talarico accepted multiple invitations, and Paxton has not. Goodwin publicly asked Patrick for three debates, Spectrum News asked Patrick’s campaign for a response, and it reported receiving none. That is the record. Texas voters can decide what to make of it. I’ve drawn my conclusion: FUCKING cowards.

Comments