By now, we all know that the Pink Panther flipping off French riot cops was a too-good-to-be-true AI fabrication, while the Portland Frog facing down Trump’s ICE gestapo is 100% legit – and has balls of steel under that inflatable costume. But questions remain about the long-term strategies of the two protest movements they symbolize.
The entirely real Portland Frog (who goes by Seth Todd when he isn’t being an inflatable superhero) has become emblematic of the Indivisible/No Kings movement that has arisen in response to the Trump Regime’s blatant unconstitutionality and inhumanity. The entirely fake Pink Panther has become a media mascot of protests currently happening in a country where they really mean it when they say “no kings” – and where protesters understand that violence against property is sometimes the only way to get the attention of the propertied class.
This is not to say that Testset is advocating French-style street violence in U.S. protests against the regime. Predictably, Trump has offered his unasked opinion that the French protests are entirely the work of immigrants of a certain color and ‘deranged’ leftists – and suggested that France should engage in exactly the sort of martial law crackdown and draconian border control he would like to see in the United States. It is rather less a question of ‘if’ he will attempt some version of martial law before being removed from the presidency (spoiler alert: he’s not leaving of his own free will), rather more a question of ‘when’ – but, more than that, a question of what resistance to the regime is prepared to do when it happens.
No Kings makes it very clear on their website that their core principles are committed to ‘nonviolent action’ and opposed to ‘civil disobedience’. This is both a stance of principality and practicality. Funding for an organization open to the idea of civil disobedience in the United States would be about as easily found as AIPAC support for Democratic Socialists. For a multitude of reasons, Indivisible (No Kings’ backing organization) cannot escalate past people in frog costumes facing off paramilitary thugs.
But that does not rule out the possibility that someone will need to.
As long as protests against the regime remain nothing more than performative theater, the effectiveness beyond giving comfortable white liberals an opportunity to vent their frustrations remains an open question. The most recent No Kings protest (October 17) focused entirely and necessarily on mobilizing as much early voting as possible. The strategy behind this is clear: the regime is going to save the real fuckery for election day through January 3rd. The more people vote early, the less the regime’s thugs and partisans have an opportunity to diminish turnout via raw intimidation.
In an open video call on October 21, senior leaders for No Kings outlined their strategy for the period between early voting and the scheduled January seating of the next U.S. Congress (which the regime can no more legally call off than they can cancel elections). That strategy focuses on preparing for mass mobilizations, monitoring ‘at risk’ states for potential election interference or fraud, and being prepared to mobilize legal rapid response teams as needed. ‘At risk’ states are defined as those that have an existing history of voter intimidation/suppression, those that have known election deniers in election management roles, and those where close races offer the regime targeted opportunities for interference.
What the strategy does not clearly define is what next steps look like if the will of the people is overturned anyway. The mere fact that there is no legal basis for failing to seat the next congress does not mean that an increasingly desperate despot may not try it anyway. Another point raised in the No Kings strategy call was the fairly blatant pro-regime interference conducted by Meta and passed off as a technical error. The tech bros who have solidly lined up behind Trump have the means to hamper legitimate organizers and use their social media platforms as outright propaganda outlets – that is, when they aren’t busy demonstrating fake flying cars.
We ain’t seen nothin’ yet.
There is, unfortunately, no organized movement prepared to take resistance to the next level, Trump bloviations and braying over ‘Antifa’ notwithstanding. And there is not likely to be one – certainly not within the fairly narrow window between now and when French-style ‘direct action’ could become a necessity. No Kings is not going to become that movement. Their previous effort at a general strike made that abundantly obvious.
In the best of all possible worlds, the current U.S. elections will result in a solid repudiation of the regime with minimal interference and a veto-proof majority in both houses of Congress – which would then, finally, be able to hold the regime accountable (whether it actually happens or not).
But after spending close to twelve years in the inverted reality Trump has inflicted upon us all, it is difficult to hope for that best outcome. Both America and No Kings need to stay true to their principles – but America, at the very least, needs to prepare for the possibility that principles not backed by direct action… may not be enough.
The ‘Paris Panther’ may be as much a fiction as the ‘Portland Frog’ is real – but the protest movement the panther has been grafted onto is real and legitimate and addresses concerns any American should recognize instantly. One of these things is, indeed, not like the other. One cannot deny the courage of people willing to face off armed paramilitaries in inflated costumes, but one equally has to wonder what those courageous people are prepared to do if asking nicely ultimately fails.
We may not have long to find out.
Images courtesy of Getty and Newsgram

Comments